John Reuter - Testimonials

Tell Us Your Story

John worked with professional ethics and expertise for us.

He kept us informed through e-mails and phone calls at each step of the process. He sent the HOA guidelines so we could make an informed decision about living in a condo. He negotiated a very beneficial purchase price. The inspector he recommended did an excellent and thorough examination of the property so we knew the items that will need repair/attention. John is a cordial well informed realtor that I highly recommend.

Shirley Mayer

John did a great job really finding out what type of house we were looking for and worked hard to find us that house.

He worked all different avenues in order to find the house for us. The money saved by using homes for heroes was tremendous! We were able to use the savings to by several things around the house. It’s awesome to see a company give benefits to those serving our country in many different aspects. John knows the market well and would be a great person to help you find a home or sell your current home.

Alec & Ashley Smith

John provided excellent service.

He was always available to answer our questions and worked extremely hard to find us the home with everything we wanted. We are first time home buyers and he made the home buying process painless-even fun! He offered great advice when we asked for it and was very knowledgeable about the process and local market. Our parents, who have experience with the buying/selling process, were also very impressed with John. We will definitely work with John again in the future and highly recommend him to our friends and family.


Very friendly and knowledgeable.

Really listened to what I was looking for and helped me through the whole process. Couldn’t be happier!

Samantha Smith

We recently purchased our first new home, John Reuter and his team did an exceptional job with showing us homes, answering any questions that we had, helping us with the ins and outs of purchasing a home as I had no clue what to do.

He kept us up to date on everything that was going on and made it less stressful for us. Even after the purchase, he still keeps in contact to make sure we are pleased with our new place. John is an absolute pleasure to work with and highly recommend him to anyone who is looking to sell or purchase!

Leah Herfel

Huge shout out to John and his team for all of the help, positivity and patience in helping us find our first home.

I recommend using this company if you want a great, low stress home buying experience. Thanks for all that you have done for us!

Vladimir & Angela Ugarte

John is the best!

He took the time to break it down for me and help me understand both the sale and the purchase of our new home! Thank you, John!

Chay McGee

Great team.

John was our primary realtor but we had the pleasure of interacting with some of his other staff. The whole process went smooth and the team was phenomenal to work with every step of the way.

Matt & Ashley Bartol

John went above and beyond to help us purchase our home.

We are extremely satisfied with his overall customer service and dedication to the home buying process. He was with us every step of the way. He made us feel at ease and ensured that ever aspect was taken care of. He also helped us get extra savings because he is a part of the Homes for Heros. We are so glad we found John and chose him as our realtor! We would definitely recomend him to our family and friends. Thank you John!

Erica Olson

When we started looking for our first home, let’s be honest, we had no clue what we were doing.

John arranged multiple showings that fit with our schedule, helped us find our dream first home, and everything has been great! He recommended some great people to do the financial and inspection aspects. We got some great use out of the home warranty that was included for FREE when we bought with him, and that alone saved us money. And we actually walked away from our closing with MORE money in the bank than we had before! We were able to turn that money right around and put it into projects for our home. I think their greatest strength was communication. John answered my million questions and requests in a timely manner and was patient as he walked us through the experience - we look forward to listing and buying again with them when it comes time to move into our “forever home”!

Karly Jo

John helped my wife and I purchase our first home recently and we couldn't be more happy.

Our situation was a bit special as we had both a VA loan and were purchasing a foreclosure and John took care of everything flawlessly. He always kept us updated as to the status of the situation and even kept in touch when things went awhile without any updates. He was open and honest through the whole process and always had our best interests in mind. I will recommend John to anyone I know who is looking to buy or sell and will definitely have him help the next time we go through this process. Thanks, John!

Trevor Klock

John helped my husband and I buy a home.

Extremely knowledgeable and easy to work with. He stayed in our price range and helped negotiate an excellent deal,especially in the sellers market that it is. I would recommend John to family and friends!

Ashley Miller

John was so helpful and patient when we were looking to purchase a house.

He took the time to show us several houses and made our buying experience very pleasant. Thank you!!

Bobbi Brown

I worked with John through the Homes for Heroes program.

He made the process low-stress and easy to understand. I also loved being able to review and sign most of the documents electronically! Definitely recommend.

Sarah Rueth

My wife and I recently purchased a home with John.

We are first time buyers and John was outstanding. He was very patient, as we really didn’t know what we wanted and looked at a lot of homes before finding ours. He made sure that the entire process was smooth and easy as possible! We would recommend John to anyone looking to buy or sell!!!! Thanks again, John.

Bob & Sarah Fanuko

My husband and I purchased our first home with The Reuter Team in October 2019.

We had been dipping our toes in the market on and off for the last 2+ years. John Reuter was incredibly helpful with the entire process, beginning to end! We never once felt pressured or misguided. I felt entirely comfortable asking any questions I had. I enjoyed the fact that I could reach out to him anytime. My husband was deployed in Afghanistan during this entire process. While that made things more difficult, I don't think I would have trusted any one else to help us get the job done! With John's military experience, he was able to help me understand what additional steps we would be required to take. This helped ease my stress and concern of being overwhelmed by not only the home buying process, but the additional processes required due to deployment. No matter what stage you are at - shopping around or ready to buy, I HIGHLY recommend choosing the Reuter Team. You won't be disappointed!

Lindsey Johnson

John and his team are FANTASTIC!

My Husband and I bought our new home and listed/sold our last one (In less than 24hrs!!) in September 2017 and still say to this day we can't get over how easy it was to work with John When we bought our 1st home it was very chaotic so dealing with John was a breath of fresh air for us! Communication is HUGE while going through the buying/selling process (especially when the market is/was crazy!) and from start to finish it was superb! He understood our work schedules were a bit crazy so it was nice to be able to call/text/email whenever! It was great to have the support from him 24/7! We can't thank John enough for all of his help and insight! If we could give more than 5 stars we would!

Elle & Grant Moxon

John was very patient with us so that we found the house we really wanted.

On several occasions he drove an hour to show us houses. Very honest, pleasant person to work with.

Home Buyer

John and team have helped us buy and sell a few homes.

They are always very helpful throughout the entire process.

Pat & Shannon McCabe

John was so helpful and patient with our crazy schedules and even did an open house in a near blizzard (shockingly that was when we got our offer)!

Thanks John, we’ve been in our new house for months now and love it more than the day we bought it!

Melissa Biel

John helped my husband and I find our perfect first home.

He helped us negotiate the price with other offers on the table to ensure that we were making a fair offer but also the most appealing one to the seller. He kept in constant contact with us and referred us to a great mortgage broker who also made the home buying process seamless for us. He made the whole process from the first showing to the closing as smooth as anyone can imagine. If you are looking for an honest and hard working realtor, he is the one for you.


My husband and I bought our first house this last March.

John was so easy to work with! I recommend them to anyone that is going through the house hunting process. They made the entire process start to finish very easy for us. I wouldn’t have wanted to go with anyone else!

Jacquelyn Willman


Easy to work with. You won't regret utilizing Mr. Reuter's services! He made sure that our first time home buying experience was stress free and a good experience.

Jacob Pederson

John did a great job in helping us go through our home buying process.

He handled a VA loan in a unique situation of an extended time before closing dates, worked through all the issues that came and did an overall fantastic job. Would definitely refer him (and actually already have). He later helped us sell that home, which was quick and an amazing experience. Also very knowledgeable in looking at lots/new home building as he helped us through that process as well. All around great realtor

Jared Braun

John was very helpful in assisting me find a home in WI while still living in AZ.

I came up for 3 days to Sun Prairie to find a condo, we looked at quite a number of homes, then the best turned up the 2nd day and we made an immediate offer. He built some extras into the contract offer and the seller agreed, so it went smoothly and I am quite happy with the result. He also was able to provide great savings for me due to the Homes for Heroes program, which saved me money in several ways. John was very easy to deal with, recommended an excellent home inspector and was available to help right up to closing and after. He has remained in contact, offering ideas and suggestions for my new living area. He proved himself as someone I could count on.

Home Buyer
Reviews on Zillow
Average Rating
"We recently purchased our first new home, John Reuter and his team did an exceptional job with showing us homes, answering any questions that we had, helping us with the ins and outs of purchasing a home ... more "
by lherfel12
"This was my first time buying a home and John made sure that this process was as stress-free and efficient as possible. John explained the process step by step, with the home buying process, along with ... more "
by fanukorp
"John was very patient with us so that we found the house we really wanted. On several occasions he drove an hour to show us houses. Very honest, pleasant person to work with. more "
by zuser20140809123057996

Property Search